1. Peyton Manning, IND. The undisputed leader of the pack for the last 5 years has now gotten that pesky “can’t win the big one” tag off his back with his Super Bowl victory in February. After his “off year” in 2005, Manning was back to his usual dominant self with another season of well over 4,000 yards and 30 touchdowns. Manning didn’t make a ton of mistakes either throwing just 9 interceptions in 16 games. To add to his impressive statistics from last year, Manning also ran for the end zone 4 times, and threw for over 300 yards 6 times. The only concern might be that he might take it easy after winning the big game last year, but from what we know of Peyton, it should only motivate him more. He’s still the best folks, worthy of a first round pick in all leagues, just after the elite running backs come off the board, somewhere between picks 5 and 7.
2. Carson Palmer, CIN. Palmer entered 2006 with a load of questions about his health. After that nasty knee injury suffered in the ‘’05 playoffs, fantasy players were scared off by the uncertainty of how he would perform. Well those owners with the sack to pick Palmer were greatly rewarded with a 4,000+ and 28 TD season. Palmer leads one of the more explosive offenses in football, with great weapons all around him. The loss of Chris Henry to suspension for the first half of the year is a slight setback, but Cincinnati has more than enough places for Palmer to throw the ball. I expect a slightly better season than last year for Carson, over 4,000 yards again and 30+ TDs. He is a late first round or second round pick.
3. Tom Brady, NE. Mr. Consistency had another solid season for the Patriots despite mediocre weapons around him. Brady threw for over 3,500 yards and 24 scores. The loss of Corey Dillon will be more than offset by the maturation of soon to be fantasy stud, Laurence Maroney. Not only that, but the Pats went out and got Brady a bunch of new toys to throw the ball to. They added Randy Moss, Donte Stallworth, and Wes Welker. This will be by far the best receiving core that Brady has ever had around him. Brady will throw for nearly 4,000 yards this year and approach 30 touchdowns. He should definitely be the third QB off the board, somewhere in the beginning of the third round.
4. Drew Brees, NO. The first season in New Orleans was a magical one for Brees and included a worst to first in the standings and a trip to the NFC title game. Head Coach Sean Payton installed a system where Brees was able to throw the ball all over the field. Brees had a career year with nearly 4,500 yards and 26 scores, as he led one of the more exciting teams in the NFC. Drew has a number of weapons around him, led by his RB tandem of Deuce McAllister and Reggie Bush, and a young, but talented group of receivers (Marques Colston, rookie Robert Meachem, David Patten, and Devery Henderson). Expect another exciting year down in the Bayou, and another productive year for Brees (3,600 yards, 28 TDs).
5. Marc Bulger, STL Bulger will be the best quarterback that gets the least amount of attention. The Rams haven’t been relevant in the standings the last 4-5 years and that has taken Bulger off the radar. However, don’t be the one to pass him by for a name you might know better. He has a trio of aging, but solid receivers (Torry Holt, Isaac Bruce, and new addition Drew Bennett), one of the best running backs in Stephen Jackson (who also caught 90 passes last year), and should be primed for another solid season of near 4,000 and 25-28 TDs.
Make or Break Year – Eli Manning, NYG. Last season was a disaster for the Giants, a .500 record, Tiki Barber announced his retirement early, there was fighting through the press, and Eli Manning’s struggles. At times he looked like the number one pick in the draft he was, at other times, he looked like he was lost out there. Sports talk radio hosts were having field days reminding fans that the Giants traded Philip Rivers, and draft picks that turned into superfreak Shawne Merriman, and kicker Nate Kaeding to acquire Manning, while the Chargers had the best record in the NFL. The first thing Eli has to improve on is the interceptions. He has thrown 35 in the last two seasons (32 games), and a number of them were at costly times during the game. In his defense, the Giants played some of the better defenses in the league (Carolina, Jacksonville, Chicago). Honestly, I think Manning’s biggest problem is that his last name is Manning. If you look at Peyton’s early career numbers, Eli isn’t far off. Unfortunately for Eli, Peyton is having his best seasons, while he is struggling in the biggest market in the world . He also has prima donna teammates who whine and cry (Plaxico Burress, Jeremy Shockey), and take plays off if they don’t feel they are getting the ball enough. I still have plenty of faith in Eli, and would feel comfortable having him as my every week starter going into this season.
Rising Star – Matt Leinart, ARI. Given the talent that he has shown in his collegiate career, and the talent of skill players around him, I can’t believe that the future for Matt Leinart isn’t incredibly bright. I think he will be making the teams that passed on him in the draft very regretful. By staying in college, Leinart gave his critics more time to nitpick his slight flaws and focus on them. But don’t forget, that Leinart was the consensus #1 pick if he had come out the year before. Edgerrin James still has a few good years left in him, and Larry Fitzgerald and Anquan Boldin are the best young receiving tandem in the NFL. If they could just find some good pieces to shore up the offensive line, the Cardinals could have an explosive offense. Grab Leinart late in your draft, and by the middle of your season he will have a good chance to be your weekly starter.
Falling Stock – Jake Delhomme, CAR. After leading his team to the Super Bowl just a couple years ago, Delhomme’s stats have started to suffer. In 2004 he threw for nearly 4,000 yards and 30 TDs. His numbers have fallen dramatically the last two years, and now the Panthers went and acquired David Carr as a kick in the butt to Delhomme. His offensive weapons (outside of Steve Smith), are decent at best. They are counting on rookie Dwayne Jarrett (whose draft stock plummeted) to come in and be their number 2 guy behind Smith, as Keary Colbert and Drew Carter really haven’t progressed. He might be a decent spot starter, but Delhomme’s time as a weekly starter is over.
Bounce Back Year – Donovan McNabb, PHI. Injuries will most likely scare a lot of fantasy players away from Donovan McNabb, and I understand that completely. When a guy has two season ending injuries in a row, that’s generally what happens. However, don’t forget what you will be getting if McNabb is able to stay healthy. He was one of the top 3 or 4 QBs in fantasy the years before his injury streak. He throws a good number of TDs (31 in 2004), and usually not a bunch of turnovers (8 INT in ’04). The Eagles brought in efficient Kevin Curtis to help anchor Philly’s no name receiving corps, and Brian Westbrook is an explosive player out of the backfield. I can’t say I expect McNabb to stay healthy all year, quarterbacks are getting hurt more now than ever, but if he is healthy, you can get an elite QB probably 3 to 4 rounds later than his value will be.
As always, your questions (adds, drops, trades) and comments are welcome at fightingchancefantasy@gmail.com. I guarantee a response within 18 hours.